All posts tagged don't ask don't tell
All posts tagged don't ask don't tell
Asked what he thought of the governor’s explanation that he “hates the sin” but “loves the sinner,” Todd Green said, “I have always hated that phrase. I think it’s impossible and you show it by action. If you love the sinner, whatever that means, your policy should reflect that I think, but in the end, I don’t understand the logic behind that at all.”
“Hate the sin, but love the sinner” is one of the worst thoughts to come out of Christianity, not only useless but harmful as well.
There is no room in a Christian for hate. Hate is not a virtue. Hate is not a Christian value. Hate is not a family value. Hate harms the hated, and it harms the hater even more. Hate is based on fear, which is not only the opposite of faith, but the rejection of faith.
One of the only two new things that Jesus said was this:
I give you a new commandment, that you love one another. Just as I have loved you, you also should love one another.
He even repeats it: Love one another as I have loved you.
Did Jesus hate sin? No. Sin frustrated Jesus, made Jesus feel pity or sadness. But hate? No way. The love Jesus showed was so complete, so merciful, so infinite and scandalous that it had no room in it for hate. To love one another as Jesus loves us is to try to see each person we encounter as God’s beloved child, to give anything — even our freedom, our bodies, our lives — so that other persons can have life.
This is the yardstick by which Christians should be measured. We are not called to hate sin; rather, we are commanded to love all persons, to love as Jesus loves us, to pray for our enemies, to love those who hate us, to forgive infinitely. You cannot do these things and still have room in your heart for hatred.
So stop hiding behind this deceitful language: it is impossible to hate the sin but love the sinner. Drop the hate. Just love.
(Source: ryking)
From a piece on the “Don’t Ask; Don’t Tell” Repeal:
The soldier facing an investigation in Baghdad said he came out to a few of his comrades in mid-March, about six weeks after Adm. Mike Mullen, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, condemned the current policy for forcing troops to lie about their sexual orientation.
At the time, the soldier and his fellow field artillery soldiers were at Camp Victory, just outside Baghdad, debating politics, the “tea party” movement and “don’t ask, don’t tell.”
“The conversation kept building, and I felt the voice inside of me screaming. If from that conversation it was not noticeable that I was gay, they were crazy,” he recalled in a blog that he started this year to protest the law.
“I am gay,” he recalled saying loudly.
After coming out to his fellow soldiers, he said he felt energized. “I was on the verge of tears and laughter,” he wrote. “I felt those same emotions that ran through my head as a teenager following the coming out to my parents.”
The next day he was told that he was being investigated. “The other day I felt honorable,” he wrote in his blog post. “Today I feel like a … criminal. I am tired. After serving this country for three years in two deployments I am no longer a soldier. I am now a prisoner.”
Although the soldier has been told that he will be allowed to finish his Iraq deployment, his fate remains unclear. In the interview, he said he’s worried that his command will restart the investigation when his unit finishes its tour.
“My biggest fear,” he said, “is what happens when we are at home and they don’t really need me any more.”
Undercover Nun weeps that this young man, this unique and precious child of God would worry that he is unneeded.
I marvel at the idea that it’s somehow okay to let a gay man finish out his tour in Iraq, but not to let him continue to serve in the military afterward. I remember hearing that the problem with gay persons serving in the military is that their fellow soldiers would somehow feel unable to count on them in combat. Does nobody remember how Jesus railed against hypocrites, against those who wield the law as a weapon?
Undercover Nun does. Shame on this young man’s superiors. Shame on our military. Shame on our government. Shame on us all.
I pray for my beloved nation, for an end to fear and hate. And I pray for this young man, for healing of the deep hurts and fears he lives with every day.
When I was in the military they gave me a medal for killing two men and a discharge for loving one.
Undercover Nun weeps for Mr. Matlovich, and for her gay and lesbian brothers and sisters in the military. It is a strange and upside-down world we live in.
Leonard, may you rest in peace and rise in glory!
Coming out as gay and knowing that you might end up losing your family for making the decision in order to remain true to yourself is a very brave and tough decision to make, however what heterogay, a Reddit user, decided to do last week takes it to a different level, He came out to his family in response to their negative attitude to gays and DADT even though he isn’t even gay!
Yes, that’s right heterogay is 100% straight, but decided that if his family couldn’t bring themselves to love him as a gay man he didn’t want to have anything to do with them, and from their response since it seems they can’t, something that heterogay admits he’s finding very hard, but feels so strongly about gay rights that he wouldn’t now have any other way.
Heterogay, you are our hero.
You can read his message about what happened below:
“I’m a straight male. Very straight. I love women.
I also totally support gay rights – with all my heart. I can’t STAND bigotry and it really pisses me off that you don’t have equal rights.
I’m straight but if I have a son or daughter that’s gay I’ll be damned if they don’t have the same rights that I do….
My family however, is fairly homophobic.
They live on the east coast. I live in SF.
I’ve never let them say anything discriminatory in front of me without it being challenged and flat out calling them hateful bigots.
Undercover Nun weeps for this young man. He ends his story thus: “So here I am…. one of you. I’m ostracized from my family. I’m out of the closet and kicked in the teeth. This is harder than I thought.”
It is indeed incredibly difficult to experience life as one of the disenfranchised. You learn a whole lot about privilege, the privilege that “majority” folks take for granted. Whether you are non-white, gay, polyamorous, non-Christian (in the US), non-Muslim (in other countries or communities), autistic, bipolar, poor, wheelchair-bound, blind, or any number of other states or conditions, all of the sudden, you see every aspect of life differently. It takes courage and strength just to exist in the same world as the privileged.
Undercover Nun has sensed what seems to be a lack of agreement as to what the Christian response to this should be. Scripture is quoted, and people are attacked (“GOD HATES FAGS” — really? Last I checked, God didn’t hate anybody!), and nobody feels very good about it. So here is where Undercover Nun stands.
So Heterogay? Undercover Nun loves you. So do a whole bunch of others. Jesus once said that he came to set father against son and mother against daughter. I’ve always been troubled by that line, but your story captures its truth.
Greater love has no one than this: that he lay down his life for his friends. Or that he lay down his family for them.
May you be blessed, brave man. You’re in my prayers.